When product lines expand to include multiple variations of a part, the question of tooling investment becomes a primary consideration. For companies that produce plastic injection molded products, particularly in the exacting field of medical devices, managing these variants without incurring prohibitive costs is a significant challenge. The traditional approach of creating a dedicated mold for each unique part can quickly become financially and logistically untenable. Fortunately, several innovative tooling strategies can provide cost-effective and efficient solutions for producing multiple part versions.
This article will explore how to handle multiple part variants with minimal tooling investment, focusing on advanced tooling services that balance upfront costs with long-term production flexibility and quality.
Developing a new product often involves creating a family of related parts. These may be components that are similar but have slight variations in size, features, or configuration. For example, a medical instrument might have handles of different sizes to accommodate various users, or an electronics enclosure may need different port cutouts for different models.
Creating a separate, dedicated injection mold for each of these variations can lead to substantial expenses and longer lead times. Each new mold represents a significant capital investment and requires its own setup, maintenance, and storage. For product lines with numerous variants, this can become a major barrier to market entry and profitability. The key to overcoming this challenge lies in adopting a more strategic and flexible approach to tooling design.
Read More About Overcoming Injection Molding Challenges in Medical Design
One of the most effective methods for managing part variants is the use of interchangeable mold inserts. This technique involves creating a single, universal mold base that can accept different, removable inserts. Each insert defines the specific geometry of a particular part variant. When a production run of a different version is needed, the current insert is simply swapped out for a new one, while the main mold base remains in the injection molding machine.
This approach offers significant cost savings because only the inserts need to be custom-machined for each new part, rather than an entire mold. This drastically reduces the initial tooling investment and shortens the lead time for producing new variants. The ability to quickly change inserts also minimizes machine downtime between production runs, enhancing overall manufacturing efficiency. Additionally, this strategy can be enhanced with plastic injection mold design services, injection molding tooling, and precise tooling solutions, which ensure the highest quality and efficiency.
However, the successful implementation of interchangeable inserts depends on careful upfront planning and robust mold design. The inserts must be precisely located and secured within the mold base to handle the high pressures of injection molding. For components with tight tolerances, such as those common in medical devices, the fit and alignment of these inserts are of utmost importance to maintain part-to-part consistency.
Another strategy for cost-effective production of multiple parts is the use of a family mold. Unlike a standard multi-cavity mold that produces several identical parts in each cycle, a family mold has cavities for different but related parts. For example, a single-family mold could produce the left and right halves of a device housing in the same cycle. This is particularly useful for products that require multiple components to be assembled.
The primary advantage of a family mold is the reduction in the number of molds required and the efficiency of producing a complete set of parts in a single machine cycle. This can lead to a lower cost per assembly. However, there are some important considerations with this method. All parts in a family mold must be made from the same plastic material. Additionally, because the parts are often different sizes and shapes, achieving a balanced flow of molten plastic into each cavity can be challenging. An unbalanced flow can lead to a variety of injection molding defects, such as short shots or warping, which can compromise the quality of the parts.
For this reason, family molds are best suited for parts that are similar in size and volume. Careful injection mold design services and skilled tool design are necessary to mitigate the risks and achieve consistent, high-quality results. This approach aligns well with plastic part design optimization and design for manufacturing solutions.
Struggling with Injection Molding Defects?
Our experts offer solutions for underfilling and overpacking in plastic injection molding.
For the ultimate in tooling flexibility and cost-efficiency, many manufacturers turn to Master Unit Die (MUD) systems. A MUD system is a standardized, reusable mold frame that accepts custom insert molds. This concept takes the idea of interchangeable inserts a step further by offering a highly standardized and modular platform.
With a MUD system, the master frame remains permanently in the injection molding press. To produce a different part, the operator simply slides out the old insert and replaces it with a new one. This can often be done in a matter of minutes, dramatically reducing setup times. The initial investment is for the master frame, and then each subsequent part variant only requires the fabrication of a much smaller and less expensive insert.
MUD systems are particularly well-suited for low- to medium-volume production runs and for products with a large number of variations. They are also an excellent option for prototyping, as they allow for rapid and cost-effective design iterations. The compact size of the inserts also simplifies storage and maintenance. This system is an excellent example of additive manufacturing services and additive manufacturing solutions, especially when used for rapid prototyping services.
Regardless of the tooling strategy chosen, the principles of Design for Manufacturing (DFM) are fundamental to success. DFM is a proactive process where the design of a part is optimized for ease of manufacturing. When dealing with multiple part variants and modular tooling, DFM becomes even more important.
Effective DFM for part variants involves designing the components in a way that maximizes the commonality between them. By identifying and preserving the shared features and isolating the variable elements, it becomes easier to create interchangeable inserts or a well-balanced family mold. A thorough DFM analysis will consider factors such as uniform wall thickness, appropriate draft angles, and the strategic placement of features to simplify mold construction and improve the quality of the final parts. This collaborative process between the product designer and the manufacturing partner is a cornerstone of a successful project.
At Aprios, we specialize in providing custom manufacturing services that are tailored to the specific needs of our clients, including those in the highly regulated medical device industry. Our expertise in interchangeable inserts, family molds, and advanced tooling strategies allows us to offer flexible and cost-effective production options for products with multiple variants. If you are looking for a partner to help you navigate the complexities of tooling for part variations, contact Aprios today to learn how we can support your project from concept to full-scale production.