3D Printing vs Injection Molding: Key Differences

3D printing and injection molding are two of the most common manufacturing processes used to produce plastic parts. While each method has distinct advantages and is suited for different applications, they are not mutually exclusive. Many projects begin with 3D Printed Prototypes using additive manufacturing services before transitioning to injection molding services for higher production volumes.

Read More About EPU 41: High-Performance Elastomeric Polyurethane Resin

The 3D Printing Process

3D printing, also known as additive manufacturing, constructs three-dimensional objects layer by layer from a digital file. The most common techniques include Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) and Stereolithography (SLA).

• From Digital Design to Machine Code: Designers first create a 3D model using Computer-Aided Design (CAD) software, often saved as a STEP file. This high-fidelity model is then typically converted into a mesh format like an STL file. Finally, slicing software interprets this file and generates G-code, which is the set of instructions that directs the 3D printer's movements.
• Printing the Part: The 3D printer executes the G-code to build the part. In FDM, a heated nozzle melts and extrudes a thermoplastic filament layer by layer. In SLA, a UV laser cures a photosensitive liquid resin, solidifying it one layer at a time.
• Post-Processing: After printing, parts often require post-processing to achieve the desired finish and mechanical properties. This can include removing support structures, sanding, polishing, curing, or applying coatings to improve strength.

Advantages of 3D Printing

• Low Initial Cost: No expensive tooling or molds are required, making it highly economical for one-off parts and low-volume production. This makes it ideal for Rapid Prototyping Services.
• Rapid Iterative Prototyping: New designs can be printed in hours or days, allowing for fast design iterations that reduce project timelines, especially important in DFM for Medical Devices.
• Design Freedom: Enables the creation of highly complex geometries, such as internal lattices and customized parts, that are impossible to produce with traditional methods.
• Short Lead Times: The time from design finalization to a finished part is very short, as no tooling needs to be created, making it ideal for Medical Device Prototypes.

Disadvantages of 3D Printing

• Material Limitations: The selection of available plastics is more limited compared to the vast library of resins available for injection molding.
• Anisotropic Part Strength: The layer-by-layer construction can create weak points between layers, meaning the part is not equally strong in all directions.
• Slower Cycle Times: Printing a single part can take several hours, making the process unsuitable for mass production.
• Surface Finish and Tolerances: Achieving very tight tolerances and a perfectly smooth surface often requires significant post-processing, which adds to time and cost.

The Injection Molding Process

Injection molding is a manufacturing process that creates parts by injecting molten material into a custom-made mold. It is the industry standard for producing later-stage prototypes and high-volume production parts using injection molding tooling.

• The Design and Material: Designers create a detailed CAD model of the part. A wide variety of thermoplastic resins can be used, including materials filled with glass or carbon fiber for added strength and durability. This phase often involves Plastic Part Design Optimization and Design for Injection Molding (DfIM).
• Creating the Tooling: A mold (or "tool"), typically made from steel or aluminum, is machined to form a cavity in the shape of the part. Steel molds are durable for high-volume production but are expensive, while aluminum molds cost less but have a shorter operational life. Aprios offers precise tooling solutions and additive manufacturing tooling to accelerate time to market.
• Molding with Heat and Pressure: Inside the injection molding press, plastic pellets are melted in a heated barrel and driven forward by a rotating screw. This molten plastic is then injected under high pressure into the mold cavity. After the plastic cools and solidifies, the mold opens, and the finished part is ejected.

Advantages of Injection Molding

• Fast Cycle Times: Once the mold is ready, parts can be produced in seconds, making it ideal for high-volume runs, including Low-Volume Injection Molding and Quick Turn Injection Molding.
  
• High Precision and Consistency: Delivers extremely tight tolerances and high part-to-part repeatability, essential in Medical Injection Molding and FDA-Compliant Manufacturing.
  
• Broad Material Selection: Compatible with thousands of types of plastics, elastomers, and silicones—critical for ISO 13485 Injection Molding and other certified applications.
  
• Isotropic Part Strength: The high-pressure molding process creates dense, uniform parts that are equally strong in all directions.
  
• Minimal Post-Processing: Parts often have an excellent surface finish right out of the mold, requiring little to no finishing work.
  

Read More About Seamless Project Management at Aprios Custom MFG

Disadvantages of Injection Molding

• High Upfront Tooling Costs: The initial investment in designing and manufacturing a mold can be substantial, although Aprios offers cost-effective tooling services for various production needs.
• Longer Initial Lead Times: Creating and testing the mold can take several weeks or even months, though Prototype Injection Molding options are available.
• Design Constraints: Geometries must be designed to allow for proper mold filling and part ejection, which restricts some complex features.
• High Cost of Changes: Any design modification requires expensive and time-consuming changes to the mold.
  

Key Considerations: 3D Printing vs. Injection Molding

• Part Volume: 3D printing excels at very low volumes (1–100 parts). For higher quantities, injection molding becomes more cost-effective as the high initial tooling cost is distributed over thousands of units.
  
• Cost: 3D printing has a low startup cost but a higher per-part cost. Injection molding has a high startup cost but a very low per-part cost at scale.
• Lead Time: 3D printing offers rapid turnaround, often within a week. Injection molding involves a longer initial lead time for tooling; Aprios can provide low-volume molds in approximately two weeks, but complex molds can take longer.
• Part Strength: Injection molded parts are generally stronger and more durable due to their solid, isotropic structure. The strength of 3D printed parts is dependent on the printing orientation and technology used.
• Design Complexity: 3D printing allows for nearly unlimited geometric complexity. Injection molding has more design restrictions, though it is perfect for a vast range of conventional part designs.

Get the Plastic Parts You Need

Choosing between 3D printing and injection molding depends on your project's specific requirements. Key factors include production volume, budget, development timeline, strength requirements, and design complexity. The experts at Aprios can help you determine the best process for your needs, offering both additive manufacturing solutions and custom injection molding solutions tailored for speed, precision, and reliability.

We’re more than just a design and manufacturing company—we’re your innovation partner. Whether you need Design for Additive Manufacturing (DfAM), injection mold design services, or end-to-end design for manufacturing services, Aprios delivers high-quality outcomes backed by deep industry expertise and advanced capabilities.